Reevaluation of the Zeiform Family Parazenidae (Teleostei, Zeiformes), with Emphasis on the Species Composition and Geographic Distribution of Parazen
Terry C. Grande, W. Leo Smith, Mark V. H. Wilson, and Randal A. Singer
Ichthyology & Herpetology 114: 633–658
Supplemental Figure 1. Molecular phylogeny of basal Acanthomorpha including Zeiformes and relevant outgroups. In this analysis, the major clade Acanthomorpha is recovered as monophyletic and highly supported. Among acanthomorphs, Lampris is sister to a clade composed of Anoplogaster + Rondeletia and the Paracanthopterygii, with 100% bootstrap support. Anoplogaster and Rondeletia form a well-supported clade that is sister to the Paracanthopterygii, and both clades are well supported (100% and 99%, respectively).
The major clade Paracanthopterygii contains two primary clades. The first clade contains Polymixia sister to a monophyletic Percopsiformes, although this relationship receives only 51% bootstrap support. An alternative position for Polymixia proposed in earlier work is as sister to all other extant paracanthopterygians (Borden et al., 2013; Grande et al., 2013, 2018). The second clade is composed of the Zeiformes and Stylephorus + Gadiformes, and it received 100% bootstrap support. Within the first clade, the clade of the Percopsiformes is well supported (100%), as are the monophyly of the Amblyopsidae (100%) and Percopsidae (100%) and the sister-group relationship between the Aphredoderidae and Amblyopsidae (100%). Within the second clade, the Gadiformes and Zeiformes are both well supported (100%) as is the sister-group relationship between the Gadiformes and Stylephoriformes (100%).
Within the Gadiformes, the seven sampled families form two primary clades, and the relationship between these clades receives 100% bootstrap support. The first clade contains the Phycidae sister to a clade composed of the Gadidae and Lotidae. Both the Phycidae + (Gadidae + Lotidae) clade and the sister-group relationship between the Gadidae and Lotidae receive 100% bootstrap support. The second clade contains two pairs of families. The family Macruronidae is sister to the Muraenolepididae, and the family Melanonidae is sister to the Trachyrincidae; both relationships receive a moderate 77% bootstrap support. These two-family pairs are themselves sister groups with 100% bootstrap support.
Supplemental Figure 2. Results of the principal components analysis of landmarks on alcohol-preserved specimens of Parazen. Specimens are plotted by their scores against PC1 vs. PC2.
Supplemental Figure 3. Results of the canonical variates analysis of X-rayed specimens of Parazen showing differences in CV1 scores among the three oceans, with Indian Ocean specimens at positive CV1 values and Atlantic Ocean specimens at negative CV1 values.
Supplemental Figure 4. Maximum-likelihood phylogeny of the Zeiformes and related acanthomorph taxa, including two additional zeiform terminals (“Zenopsis sp.” from Lin et al. [2025] and “Cyttula macropus” from Ba [2026], bolded in figure) incorporated after acceptance of this manuscript. The original analyses included eight Sanger-sequenced loci for 51 terminals, totaling 6,368 base pairs, and genomic-scale UCE data for 31 species, totaling 184,792 base pairs. We repeated the analyses described in the main text with the addition of these two representative terminals, incorporating sequences available on GenBank from Lin et al. (2025) and Ba (2026). The additional sequences included mitochondrial 12S (PZ012201), 16S (PZ006375), and COI (PQ524198, PX945068), and nuclear GLYT (PZ017012), as recognized by Ba (2026: table 2). We excluded the MYH6, PLAGL2, and SH3PX3 sequences attributed to Cyttula macropus by Ba (2026) because the corresponding GenBank records contain GLYT sequences rather than the indicated MYH6, PLAGL2, and SH3PX3 loci. Branches labeled 2×, 3×, or 5× should be interpreted as two, three, or five times longer than drawn, respectively.